Look at this:
lichess.org/training/66778
I solved it, but I wonder: Is the advantage so obvious?
Sure, after the main line Stockfish shows some +3.2 or something - but there is no material advantage, because White cannot evade losing a piece back (either Ng5 or Bh7). After 5 more moves of either side (main line of the Stockfish analysis) White finally does gain material (rook for bishop) - but you can make a lot of mistakes till then. And usually you can't compute all of this when initially playing Bh7.
Maybe I would play the line in a game because I can see: I will not lose material, and my attck looks pretty - but for me it is not a definite win.
So my question is: Do you think the puzzle finishes too early? Or do you guys really consider it complete?
lichess.org/training/66778
I solved it, but I wonder: Is the advantage so obvious?
Sure, after the main line Stockfish shows some +3.2 or something - but there is no material advantage, because White cannot evade losing a piece back (either Ng5 or Bh7). After 5 more moves of either side (main line of the Stockfish analysis) White finally does gain material (rook for bishop) - but you can make a lot of mistakes till then. And usually you can't compute all of this when initially playing Bh7.
Maybe I would play the line in a game because I can see: I will not lose material, and my attck looks pretty - but for me it is not a definite win.
So my question is: Do you think the puzzle finishes too early? Or do you guys really consider it complete?